Magic Ring vs. Chain Start: Which Crochet Method Is Best for Beginners?
If you’re new to crochet or just starting your first amigurumi project, you’ve probably come across the debate: magic ring (also called magic circle) vs. chain start. Which one is easier? Which one gives your project the best results?
This is one of the most common beginner crochet questions I hear—and today, I’ll walk you through the pros and cons of each method so you can feel confident starting your next project.
What Is the Magic Ring in Crochet?
The magic ring (or magic circle) is a technique where you crochet stitches directly into a loop of yarn and then pull it closed. When tightened, the center cinches completely shut, leaving no gap or hole.
This is why the magic ring is considered the gold standard for amigurumi crochet—it gives stuffed animals, plushies, and toys a professional, seamless finish. No stuffing pokes through, and the center looks polished.
✅ Pros: Gap-free center, perfect for amigurumi.
⚠️ Cons: Tricky at first, may loosen if not secured.
Pro tip: Always weave in your tail securely to keep it from loosening over time.
Listen to my podcast episode about the magic ring and alternatives.
Crochet Chain Start Methods (2 Alternatives)
If the magic ring feels like a tangled puzzle, don’t worry—you have options! Two common chain start methods work especially well for beginners.
Chain 3 + Slip Stitch:
● Start with a slipknot.
● Chain 3, then slip stitch into the first chain to form a ring.
● Add 6 single crochets into the ring.
This method is simple and works well with bulky chenille yarn since the small hole is barely noticeable.
Chain 2 + Crochet in First Chain:
● Make a slipknot and chain 2.
● Place 6 single crochets in the first chain.
● The stitches naturally form a small round.
This is a fast, easy alternative if you’re not ready for the magic circle.
✅ Pros: Easy for beginners, quick setup.
⚠️ Cons: Leaves a small hole, especially with thinner yarn.
Which Crochet Start Should You Use?
For amigurumi plushies: The magic ring is the best choice for a professional, gap-free finish.
For beginners just learning crochet: Start with a chain method to build confidence and stitch control. Once you feel ready, circle back to the magic ring—it will click with practice!
Think of it this way:
... Chain start = easier, but with a hole.
... Magic ring = harder at first, but gives that flawless, tight center.
Beginner Crochet Tip: Practice Makes Perfect
When I first learned the magic ring, I had to re-watch video tutorials every time. Now, it’s second nature. The trick is consistency—practice it a few times on small projects until it sticks.
If you want a step-by-step demo, check out my YouTube tutorial on the magic ring. Seeing it in action will make it so much easier.
Final Takeaway
Both methods work—but if you want your amigurumi plushies to look seamless, the magic ring wins. Don’t stress if it feels impossible at first. Start with what feels comfortable, and then level up to the magic ring when you’re ready.
Crochet is supposed to be fun. Whether you start with a chain or a circle, what matters most is enjoying the process and celebrating every project you finish!
About the Author
Marcy Gardner is the crochet designer behind Simply Hooked, where she creates beginner-friendly amigurumi patterns that help makers of all skill levels create adorable, giftable plushies.
With over 13 years of crochet experience, Marcy has taught hundreds of crocheters through her patterns, kits, and online courses.
